Study in: India USA UK France Canada Australia
University News

Supreme Court audit of private universities gets a new bench before November 19 hearing

By TUF News Desk · Published 17 November 2026 · 4 min read

Fact-checked against 2+ independent sources · Editorial policy

Amity University's D Block in Noida (representative image)
Amity University's D Block in Noida (representative image) · Photo: Anuvrat Parashar, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

The Supreme Court case that put private universities across India under a financial scanner will now be heard by a different set of judges. Bar and Bench reported today that the case, Ayesha Jain v. Amity University Noida and Others, has moved from the bench of Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah to a new three-judge bench led by Justice Vikram Nath. Justices R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh will sit with him. The next hearing is on November 19 at 2 pm, and the court record gives no reason for the change.

The earlier bench had driven the case hard for a year. Justices Amanullah and N. V. Anjaria heard it as a part-heard matter through October, turning a single student’s complaint into a countrywide check on how private universities are set up, funded and regulated.

How one student’s complaint became a national audit

Ayesha Jain, 23, went to court in mid-2025 after Amity University, Noida refused to update her name in its records. She had legally changed her name from Khushi Jain, and she said the university barred her from classes and made her lose an academic year. The bench pulled up the university’s top officials over her treatment. Instead of closing the case after giving her relief, it widened the scope in November 2025 to examine private universities across the country.

In the same month, the court told the Cabinet Secretary, the chief secretaries of every state and Union Territory, and the UGC chairman to file affidavits in their own names, with details of land allotments, statutory relaxations and governing body structures of private universities. When the Centre filed through its higher education secretary instead, the bench objected and said it had shown restraint by not summoning the Cabinet Secretary to court.

What the September order asked for

On September 17, 2026, the bench ruled that no private university can be run as a profit-making institution. States were told to collect five years of audited accounts from private universities, along with fee structures, how surplus funds were used, faculty recruitment, classes actually held, and how student complaints were handled. The affidavits were due within six weeks of the order.

The case also reached fake colleges. On October 9, the bench acted on a report about a purported medical college running from a farmhouse in Uttar Pradesh’s Etah district, with an illiterate tea seller listed as its chairman. The court directed the UGC and all regulators to issue public advisories warning students to verify an institution before taking admission, as covered in our earlier report on the fake colleges advisory.

What students should check before paying fees

The simplest check is the UGC’s list of fake universities on its official website. A name missing from that list is not proof of recognition, so students should also confirm the university’s legal status and whether the specific course has approval from the relevant regulator. Our guide to choosing a university in India walks through these checks, from accreditation to fee receipts.

Before paying admission fees, visit the campus. Check that the address on record is where the college actually functions and that classes are running. A glossy brochure is not proof that an institution can award a valid degree.

Frequently asked questions

Why has the private universities audit case moved to a new bench?

Bar and Bench reported on November 17 that the case was reassigned from Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah’s bench to a three-judge bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath. The court record gives no reason for the change.

When is the next hearing in the private universities audit case?

November 19, 2026, at 2 pm, before Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh.

What did the Supreme Court order private universities to disclose?

Five years of audited accounts, fee structures, fund utilisation, surplus investments, faculty recruitment, classes actually conducted and grievance redressal, under the court’s September 17, 2026 order.

How can I check whether a university is genuine before paying fees?

Check the UGC’s fake universities list, confirm the university’s legal status and the course’s approval from the relevant regulator, and visit the campus before paying fees.

Frequently asked questions

Why has the private universities audit case moved to a new bench?

Bar and Bench reported on November 17 that the case was reassigned from Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah's bench to a three-judge bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath. The court record gives no reason for the change.

When is the next hearing in the private universities audit case?

November 19, 2026, at 2 pm, before Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh.

What did the Supreme Court order private universities to disclose?

Five years of audited accounts, fee structures, fund utilisation, surplus investments, faculty recruitment, classes actually conducted and grievance redressal, under the court's September 17, 2026 order.

How can I check whether a university is genuine before paying fees?

Check the UGC's fake universities list, confirm the university's legal status and the course's approval from the relevant regulator, and visit the campus before paying fees.

Sources: Bar & Bench, Live Law, Deccan Herald